Is canal project in jeopardy?

Today’s blog question:  What do you think the best use is for the funds from the sale of Brighton Beach, rumoured to be between $25-30 million?  Email or write your suggestions below.

_____________________________

“We can’t afford to throw money at this,” said Coun. Jo-Anne Gignac. “Our industrial tax base is disappearing, our residential taxpayers are losing their jobs. At the same time, we have a stream of people saying help us. Where are we going to get the money?”

I can’t wait for the discussion regarding the city’s proposed canal project for downtown.  At a cost of upwards of $50-million plus land acquisition it will be interesting to hear the arguments for funding it.

Because how can city councillors cry poor over a $450,000 loan request to the Art Gallery of Windsor while in the next breath find the truck loads of cash required to begin a phased construction – the most expensive way to undertake this project incidentally.

And there could be a fly in the ointment known as Mayor Francis’ “vision” of seeking infrastructure dollars from the provincial and federal governments to realise it.

570 News in Cambridge, Ontario reported that Infrastructure Minister George Smitherman told Cambridge city council they’ve “got to have priorities.”

Cambridge city council is being told to choose between an expanded Cambridge Memorial Hospital or a new arts centre:

…When asked about funding for Cambridge Memorial Hospital and the new arts centre in Cambridge for Drayton Theatre, George Smitherman told The Record, quote, “you’ve got to have priorities and sometimes one has to give way to the other.”

Mayor Doug Craig says even if the province pulls the funding for the arts centre, the city will find another source of money.

What will it be in Windsor?  The airport cargo hub?  Investments into providing serviceable land?  The College Avenue bridge; the $300-million plus in watermain and sewer projects highlighted in the city’s infrastructure wish list - or the “canal”?

Mayor Francis has been quite clear the canal project is an “infrastructure” project, as the July 29, 2008 Windsor Star reported:

 ”The city is not getting involved with any of the developments,” he said. “The city will be doing what we should be — investing in infrastructure. By doing this, we give the city a chance to do bigger and better things.

And the Mayor also hinted on A-News that federal and provincial infrastructure money may be available – a point reiterated by BIA spokesperson, Larry Horwitz in front of the space ship sculpture on the riverfront:

“It could be a new view of what the city can be and what the city should become,” he said. “But it can’t be rinky dink. You need to take time to do it right.”

The project is doable financially, but will need support from the provincial and federal government, Horwitz said (April 3, 2009, Windsor Star).

But given the Hon. George Smitherman’s words to Cambridge city council, is the canal project in jeopardy before it is even out of the gates?  Will he tell Windsor city council to set their priorities – their infrastructure wish list or a 300 meter long canal?

Or will city council “decide” to use the funds from the sale of Brighton Beach to the Federal government to pour into the canal project?

Or is this just another exercise in a desperate attempt by the Mayor and council to portray our provincial MPPs as having no clout at Queen’s Park over their stance as it relates to the city’s Greenlink proposal?

Because if the city cannot afford a mere $450,000 loan, how can city council, in the Mayor’s own words:

…discuss putting aside some funding for the canal project before it completes its budget deliberations over the next month, Francis said.

In Eddie I trust!  See how easy it is…

11 Responses

  1. Note to Council: Fix the roads. Fix the sewers. Fix the watermains. Fix the sidewalks. Enough said.

  2. That is what caught my eye as well Chris! The city can’t afford a LOAN with a 3% return over a decade but they will afford to spend $50 million plus for a canal?

    I think the $30 million should go towards infrastructure. Not more road widenings or any of that nonsense. But fix the roads we have while fixing the watermains (read: Not new ones but pipe lining them). That $30 million could go a long way in helping people to keep raw sewage from entering their basements and it might alleviate the WUC bills too!
    Plus the city could still tender an urban village. The citizens get the best of both worlds.

    But then no one gets their backs scratched so the above will not happen.

  3. send our fearless leader and his lapdogs on a one way all inclusive trip to pluto.

  4. I think you guys should all give your heads a shake.

    The Art Gallery has a long history in Windsor, a track record that upon analysis we can all see is NOT an economic generator, is NOT a tourist attraction, is NOT a focal point for area development. What it is, is a fancy hang-out for the local wine and cheese party set, the same group of people that have run Windsor into the ground over the past 30 years.

    But a canal is something everyone can enjoy, and walk around and experience and be proud of. And it will spur residential developments alongside it, bring tourists, maybe millions a year, to downtown Windsor, and just imagine if they only spend $5 per person on average during a visit – we’ll have generated millions in economic activity for the Windsor area. This investment is a no-brainer.

    Fix roads? Fix sewers? How does that improve our lot? It just makes for nicer roads running in front of umpteen houses for sale on every street. We need bold daring investments in our future that will spur our renaissance as a place to be! Bring on the canal!

    In Eddie we trust.

  5. In Eddie we trust! love it.

  6. A reader writes:

    Chris,

    The City should buy all the equipment necessary to have Windsor to print its own currency, dubbed the Edeuro (your words, not mine).

    Just think, the City could make every taxpayer use the Edeuro to pay its property taxes, Enwin bills, license fees, etc. The possibilities are endless.

    Of course the City could hire Mark Meldrum, the business professor at the University of Windsor, to oversee this venture. They can use his genius idea to print scrip money. For us common folk we would see it as money with a best before date. See the article below.

    http://www2.canada.com/windsorstar/news/story.html?id=bc1dffdc-7601-4870-8b10-b1b4f807c989

    Just think, the City could earn even more money when people don’t use up all their Edeuros and have to renew for a small fee.

    Pure Genius!

    Signed,

    The Newest Member of “In Eddie I Trust”

  7. More on Scrip Money. Had no idea what that was.

    http://peakenergy.blogspot.com/2008/10/locabucks-are-local-currencies-way-to.html

  8. Are we ‘world class’ yet? No? Drat!
    These egomaniacal halfwits have been daydreaming about ‘legacy’ projects ever since Djoser built the first pyramid – well, Djoser is credited with building the first pyramid, but you can be sure he personally never laid a single brick. Since that time, nothing much has changed.
    Eddies moat has got to be the stupidest idea I’ve ever heard in my life.
    Remember all the office jobs Candarel was going to create? Remember all the convention tourism sure to fill the Cleary?
    Remember all the people who came from far and wide to see the big hole in the ground downtown?
    Once upon a time Flint, Mich decided to ‘create jobs’ by building a ‘world class’ attraction called ‘AutoWorld’. Hundreds of millions were blown by local council yokels on this foolish pipe-dream, you know, to ’save the economy’ and ‘create jobs’.
    Now of course, like Candarel, it’s just a sad joke, for which the taxpayers are still paying.
    Government cannot CREATE JOBS.
    Government cannot CREATE ANYTHING.
    The job of government is simply to provide basic services and manage the tax money we give them, not play Walt Disney on hare-brained legacy projects with taxpayer money.
    Oh, it’s a no-brainer all right. Blackhelicopters starts out dumping on the art gallery – I agree! It’s ALL TRUE.
    Then he/she/it inexplicably goes on to support this imbecilic project – I smell vested interest.
    Looks like blackhelicopters has been standing too close to the rotor blades again.

  9. PS: since no ethical person could ever get elected into government at any level, I suggest all public servants should first have to swear an oath similar to the physicians code that starts out: FIRST DO NO HARM

    This principle must be applied in every situation/circumstance where taxpayer money is being spent, and where our glorious ‘leaders’ (professional liars, unprincipled fools, and sociopaths) don’t really know what to do. (which is almost always)

    FIRST, DO NO HARM!

  10. Methinks J-Lo you aren’t reading the current affairs sections of the newspapers…. activist government is here to stay, for a long long time, from people crying for bailouts of their industries, to the US government forcing the resignation of a CEO, to government insurance of mortgages and on and on. With the election of Obama, the West came to a fork in the road and chose a very different path from the one travelled the past 30 years.

    Your idea of what government is supposed to do is now archaic, and has been relegated to the scrap heap of history, along with the rest of small ‘c’ conservative ideologically beliefs. Our own PM, once a dyed-in-the-wool fiscal conservative, has abandoned all principle in the pursuit of maintaining power and now runs around the world preaching the virtues of inflationary government stimulus. The US? Reagan is shuddering in his grave over the sudden remaking of that country into an interventionist pseudo-socialist state since Clinton left office.

    So you call it a legacy project, we call it par for the course, and given the thirst for government action, why not a canal? Why waste money on roads and bridges and sewers and watermains? Do these get politicians re-elected? Are these sexy projects that make a community proud? How many people travel out of town and brag that “hey Windsor is pretty boring, but at least we’ve got great roads and sewers’. Nobody cares. People care about big – MEGA – solutions. Gord Henderson speaks for all Windsorites when he longs for something spectacular to happen in the Region.

    In Eddie we trust.

  11. I agree with most of this, and certainly agree that ethics are relic of the past.

Comments are closed.